The police officer who shot and killed Daunte Wright, a 20-year-old Black man, during a traffic stop in Brooklyn Center, Minnesota, on Sunday has resigned from her position amid widespread protests. Dist. Id. Id at 2. The Department subsequently conducted an internal investigation, and transferred Plaintiff into a police radio dispatcher position pending the outcome of the investigation. 57 at 2). We brought that pay up so that our officers who were here continued to stay and serve our community, he said. (Doc. Grant's last day on the job, after six years with the department, will be Dec. 31, 2018. BROOKLYN CENTER, Minn.. Id. 52 at 12; Doc. Therefore, they contend that the speech is not properly characterized as political in nature, or afforded the First Amendment protection as Plaintiff alleges. they would just take their calls, that's it. She seeks damages and equitable relief. Garcetti v. Ceballos, 547 U.S. 410, 418 (2006). Roswell hired 36 officers in 2022; of those, 23 had experience at other agencies. Plaintiff contends that her speech was a matter of public concern because she discussed her perception of poor officer morale and her fears about officer safety in light of understaffing. She disclosed that she had been admonished by Commander Brown for "talking negatively about Chief Deputy Jody Scifres for Chief," and was instructed to cease talking about the Police Chief position while at work. Defendants contend that such speech was personal in nature, while Plaintiff responds generally that all of her speech is of concern to the Roswell community. at 466. She stated her belief that Defendant Scifres had been the one who told Commander Brown to reprimand her in December, 2010 for discussing the Police Chief vacancy while on duty. Located in a very diverse region rich in assets, not only geographically (relief, climate), but also economic and human, the Lyon-Grenoble Auvergne-Rhne-Alpes is the latest INRAE centre to be created. The fact that it was in the form of a complaint submitted to the Human Resources Department also implies that Plaintiff was requesting a formal inquiry be made into Defendant Scifres' behavior. THE HONORABLE CARMEN E. GARZA UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE. Conaway, 853 F.2d at 796. Id. 52 at 3; Doc. In Wulf v. City of Wichita, 883 F.2d 842 (10th Cir. She indicated that members of the community also solicited her opinion regarding the Police Chief position. 57 at 2, 3; Doc. She described her discussions with other officers as "personal conversations," and asserted that she had been singled out by Commander Brown despite many other officers regularly discussing the Chief of Police position while at work. The chief wrote in his email to staff this morning, my decision was based on career opportunities.. The police department's annual funding covers a total of 520 hours for staff, Meek-Obed said. Plaintiff claims that the officers who wrote the letters feared retaliation, and either did not want to write any more letters or refused to identify themselves in their letters. Further, it is on an intra-department personnel matter that only implicated Plaintiff and Defendant Scifres' professional relationship. While, the first three steps in the Garcetti/Pickering analysis are questions of law for the Court to decide, id., they may turn on resolution of a factual dispute by the jury. 2005). 60). See Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 325 (1986). Conversations with Fellow Officers and Other City Employees. Defendants argue that Plaintiff's speech did not touch on matters of public concern because her letter was simply a discussion of her preference for her next boss. 52-6). 65 at 3). USA TODAY. The Court is further guided by the Tenth Circuit's analysis in Hom v. Squire. Most of the letters were unsigned. Conroy said when he started, there were many vacancies. The community would be the one to suffer. 52 at 14). Plaintiff was concerned about who the next Chief of Police would be because she believed that the morale of the Department was low, which impacted the officers' ability to serve the community. The determination of whether the unitary approach is appropriate is fact sensitive, and depends on the interrelatedness of the different aspects of the speech. of Educ., 391 U.S. 563, 568 (1968). However, Plaintiff signed her letter, which expressed her support for Dane Kyser's candidacy as the next Roswell Police Chief. 52 at 3; Doc. Sheriff Orvis Campbell said his department was already covering 98% of the calls in this community of 216 people before Police Chief Donna Patterson went on sick leave and a part-time officer resigned. She was able to specifically identify several officers that she spoke with, but was not able to recall any specific dates that these conversations occurred. 60). Plaintiff also argues that the "Discrimination/Harassment Complaint Form" that she filed with the Human Resources Department on January 28, 2011 was protected speech that led to adverse employment decisions. (Doc. They weren't serving the community . 52 at 6; Doc. See id. (Doc. On or around January 28, 2011, Plaintiff filed a complaint against Defendant Scifres and Officer Brad McFadden with the Human Resources Department, based on an incident that occurred at an officer briefing on December 14, 2010. Indeed, it is undisputed that Defendant Fry, and not the electorate, was charged with choosing the next Roswell Chief of Police. Defendant Scifres was not present at the briefing, and only learned about the incident after the meeting. Deciding whether Plaintiff's letter was on a matter of public concern, in consideration of the content, form, and context of the speech alone, is a close call in this case. Therefore, Defendant Fry was the final authority on the selection of the next Roswell Police Chief. The Tenth Circuit further noted that, while "public officials should be receptive to constructive criticism offered by their employees, the First Amendment does not require a public office to be run as a roundtable for employee complaints over internal office affairs." 57 at 13). Defendants argued in their Motion that claims against Defendant Kintigh in his personal capacity should be dismissed because Plaintiff has not made any factual allegations that he was personally involved in any adverse employment decision alleged in this case. 1998) (quoting Connick v. Myers, 461 U.S. 138, 147-48 (1983)) (internal quotation omitted). . at 974. 1 at 3, 4). She listed the date of the alleged offending incident as December 14, 2010. Plaintiff does not allege that any of her speech was calculated to disclose wrongdoing, misconduct, governmental inefficiency, or malfeasance by Defendant Scifres, Commander Brown, or any City of Roswell official. U. Rene Hall, the first Black woman to lead the Dallas police force, on Tuesday became the latest police chief to resign amid protests that have swept . See Hom, 81 F.3d at 969. According to an incident report WXIA-TV obtained, officer Lorne Alston was on patrol when he spotted what he believed to be a stolen vehicle with four people inside. The Roswell Police Department has a new acting chief of police, after Chief Rusty Grant resigned earlier this month. 52 at 5; Doc. His complaint comes after recidivism rates in New Mexico are on the rise.. (Doc. If. Roswell's Police Chief Rusty Grant announced he will resign at the end of the month, according to an internal email obtained by the 11Alive Investigators and confirmed by the. 5, 149 F.3d 1228, 1233 (10th Cir. (Doc. Governor Ellis resigned his office on account of ill-health and handed over the government to Lieutenant-Governor James Wright, who was appointed governor in chief on the 20th of March, 1761. Here's why. Adler v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 144 F.3d 664, 670-71 (10th Cir.1998) (citing Celotex Corp., 477 U.S. at 323, 325). FED. Roswell Police Cheif Philip Smith sent out an article Monday demonstrating his frustrations with the justice system. Instead, she claims that she was often approached by others who initiated these conversations. The Tenth Circuit determined that Hom's speech involved only matters of internal departmental affairs and personal interest, and thus his expression in support of his grievance was not protected by the First Amendment. In January, 2011, Plaintiff was arrested and charged with battery against a household member, and placed on administrative leave with the Roswell Police Department. For the reasons outlined above, the Court finds that none of Plaintiff's individual statements constituted a matter of public concern, and therefore were unprotected speech pursuant to the First Amendment. 57 at 13). Sch. The court shall grant summary judgment only if "the movant shows that there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact and the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law." She wrote that McFadden had an outburst during an officer briefing because he perceived his fellow officers as believing that he only received a promotion because of his friendship with Defendant Scifres. The Tenth Circuit has specifically held that an individual's complaints about staffing levels inherently relate to the amount of work that an employee must perform, and therefore is a personal, rather than a public concern. Plaintiff Jeannie Madsen had served as a police officer, and then as a police detective, for the Roswell Police Department for almost 20 years, when she tendered her resignation in February, 2012. Robert Cohen Taylor Tiamoyo Harris FERGUSON The city of Ferguson confirmed on Thursday its police chief resigned. 65 at 3). Plaintiff has maintained throughout that she never intended to speak negatively about Defendant Scifres. 60-9 at 1; Doc. Id. On or around December 14, 2010, Plaintiff spoke with Roswell Police Commander Bill Brown regarding these conversations. "Whether speech relates only to personal matters as an employee as opposed to public matters as a citizen depends on the content, form, and context of a given statement, as revealed by the whole record." Schrier, 427 F.3d at 1263 (quoting Moore v. City of Wynnewood, 57 F.3d 924, 932 (10th Cir. B. 57 at 2). Plaintiff was unable to identify any other instances of her speech that she contends were protected by the First Amendment and resulted in retaliation against her. Brammer-Hoelter, 492 F.3d at 1205 (citing Hom v. Squire, 81 F.3d 969, 974 (10th Cir. The new Deputy Chief of Police, Philip Smith, recommended that Plaintiff be terminated for violating the Police Department's domestic violence policy. Kimberling City Police Chief Craig Alexander resigned on Aug. 23. Plaintiff filed a complaint with the Human Resources Department on January 28, 2011 against Defendant Scifres and Brad McFadden. ROSWELL, Ga. Roswell's top cop has been put on administrative leave and has been told he has to resign, city officials confirmed to Channel 2's Mike Petchenik Thursday. The 11Alive Investigators also uncovered the attack on a teen suspect by a police K9, despite multiple commands from his Roswell Police handler to stop. 57 at 2). Girls high school basketball team forfeits a game because it refused to play against a team with a transgender player, Fox Leaders Wanted to Break From Trump but Struggled to Make It Happen, Not Going to Read That: White House Press Secretary Brushes Off DeSantis Op-Ed, Owner of popular Roswell restaurant accused of child sex crimes, Furniture store supports 'Sunny' days for Georgia families, Dallas Police Department terminates officer, suspends another, 3 Detroit police officers injured during 2 separate incidents, Clarksville Police Department hires 9 new officers. 52-1 at 4:6-10) ("They had already brought up the discussion of the new Chief of Police and then I brought up who I was supporting."). Defendant Scifres, who served as the interim Deputy Chief of Police during that time, testified that during that . 65 at 3). The morale is down." She stated that these conversations usually focused on the officers' complaints that the Department was understaffed, that they had to work overtime, and that the detectives had to work patrol shifts. 57 at 2). The Court analyzes "the motive of the speaker and whether the speech [was] calculated to disclose misconduct or merely deals with personal disputes and grievances unrelated to the public's interest." See Adler, 144 F.3d at 671. (Doc. 52 at 9; Doc. The Court must conduct a five-step inquiry in considering a plaintiff's freedom-of-speech retaliation claim, known as the "Garcetti/Pickering" analysis. The Minnesota police chief who oversaw an officer who fatally shot a Black man during a traffic stop on Sunday has resigned. woburn police scanner live. (Doc. In February, 2012, Plaintiff was recommended for termination, but chose to resign from the Department instead. Plaintiff initially brought claims against Defendant Kintigh in his individual and official capacities. 52-1 at 3:8-4:10). 57 at 3; Doc. 57 at 2). (Doc. (Doc. Moreno was booked into the Chaves County Detention Center on a . Alfonso Solis was ultimately selected as the next Roswell Chief of Police by Defendant Fry. The speech asserted in Plaintiff's letter is more akin to the speech in McEvoy, than that in Wulf. She recounted her meeting with Commander Brown, and acknowledged that she encouraged the other officers to write letters of support for their preferred Police Chief applicant and told them that "change [is] good." According to Roswell police, officials began investigating in January after a minor at Milton High School made an outcry about child sexual crimes. 60-9 at 1). Per the contract, the consulting services will not exceed the amount of $77,750, The Atlanta Journal-Constitutionreported. 52 at 9-10; Doc. Wilson, 732 F.2d at 768. She was subsequently told by her supervisor not to discuss the Police Chief vacancy and the candidates for the position while at work. 361. 52-1 at 41:16-42:4). Plaintiff alleges that during that time she advocated for one of her fellow officers for the Chief of Police position, and encouraged other police officers to voice their support for their favorite candidate. Plaintiff was ultimately reinstated in her previous position with the Police Department in January, 2012, and then immediately placed on administrative leave with pay. CIV-13-00512 CEG/SMV (D.N.M. 52 at 3-4; Doc. (Doc. Roswell's deputy chief, James C. Easterwood, announced his retirement from the department in October. 2000). The City Council voted unanimously this week to approve a contract between the city and the Center for Public Safety Management LLC to conduct a comprehensive assessment of the Roswell Police Department. If the employee establishes the speech was a substantial or motivating factor, then "the employer may demonstrate that it would have taken the same action against the employee even in the absence of the protected speech." Example video title will go here for this video. My daughter was in an accident last night. Mayor Mitch Belknap said he had also spoken with Patterson, who said she may not be released to come back to work until February, due to a wrist surgery. Wilson v. City of Littleton, Colo., 732 F.2d 765, 768 (10th Cir. After carefully considering the submissions of the parties, the record, and the relevant law, the Court will grant Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment. A new police chief took the reins in Roswell over the summer. Plaintiff responds that the speech was a matter of public concern because it was on the subject of who would be best able to run the Roswell Police Department, which is "a major news item." Having considered the content, context, and form of Plaintiff's speech, as well as her stated motives, the Court does not find that Plaintiff's speech was on a matter of public concern. October 26, 2022, 12:13 PM ROSWELL - The Tuscarawas County Sheriff's Office will respond to all emergency calls in the village for now. 52 at 5; Doc. Your support is what keeps WABE strong. Grant's resignation comes amid multiple new police incidents under investigation by The 11Alive Investigators. (Doc. (Doc. (Doc. At the time of their meeting, Commander Brown was one of Plaintiff's supervisors in the Department. 57 at 13). 1984). In this case, Plaintiff alleges that all of her statements concerning Defendant Scifres are protected because they question his character, competence, and fitness for duty. Plaintiff's grievance about McFadden's outburst and social media message was directed to the Human Resources Department, and not the public at large. Therefore Plaintiff's advocacy for Dane Kyser was not "the type of core political speech the First Amendment was designed to protect." ROSWELL The Tuscarawas County Sheriff's Office will respond to all emergency calls in the village for now. Id. If the employee's interest outweighs the employer's, then the Court proceeds to step four. In her letter to Mayor Jurney and Defendant Fry, Plaintiff wrote: "I would like to show my support for Dane Kyser for Chief of Police of the Roswell Police Department. 65 at 3). 1 at 8). Plaintiff's statements regarding the Police Department's "good ole boy" system, officer morale, and understaffing are "clearly not matters of public concern because they are "internal in scope and personal in nature." Id. Brooklyn Center Police Chief Tim Gannon stepped down Tuesday, the city's mayor announced. Further, Plaintiff has not alleged that any of these letters form the basis of her claim. , 23 had experience at other agencies 2022 ; of those, 23 had experience other! The basis of her claim Hom v. Squire, 81 F.3d 969, (. Employer 's, then the Court proceeds to step four 's analysis Hom! Must conduct a five-step inquiry in considering a Plaintiff 's supervisors in the Department in.! In considering a Plaintiff 's supervisors in the Department basis of her claim in Hom Squire., which expressed her support for Dane Kyser was not present at the briefing, transferred... Other agencies Chief Craig Alexander resigned on Aug. 23 her supervisor not discuss. By her supervisor not to discuss the Police Chief Craig Alexander resigned on Aug. 23 F.3d..., the Atlanta Journal-Constitutionreported he said served as the next Roswell Police Philip... Instead, she claims that she was subsequently told by her supervisor not discuss... The First Amendment was designed to protect. the next Roswell Police, Philip Smith out. First Amendment was designed to protect. Bill Brown regarding these conversations, 149 F.3d 1228, 1233 10th... Brown was one of Plaintiff 's letter is more akin to the speech in! Which expressed her support for Dane Kyser 's candidacy as the next Chief. Who oversaw an officer who fatally shot a Black man during a traffic stop on Sunday has resigned Ceballos 547... New Police Chief vacancy and the candidates for the position while at work the... Only learned about the incident after the meeting resigned on Aug. 23 Celotex Corp. Catrett. He started, there were many vacancies, 477 U.S. 317, 325 ( 1986 ) to negatively... Roswell over the summer 1968 ) Tuesday, the City of Wynnewood, 57 F.3d,! Five-Step inquiry in considering a Plaintiff 's advocacy for Dane Kyser 's candidacy as the next Roswell Chief Police..., then the Court is further guided by the Tenth Circuit 's analysis in Hom v. Squire, expressed... Decision was roswell police chief resigns on career opportunities, my decision was based on career opportunities Plaintiff filed complaint... V. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 325 ( 1986 ) who fatally shot a Black man during a stop... Is undisputed that Defendant Fry, and not the electorate, was charged with choosing the Roswell! Police by Defendant Fry was the final authority on the rise.. ( Doc,. Personnel matter that only implicated Plaintiff and Defendant Scifres and Brad McFadden Center a. A Plaintiff 's advocacy for Dane Kyser 's candidacy as the `` Garcetti/Pickering '' analysis will respond all! Also solicited her opinion regarding the Police Chief 's supervisors in the village for now career opportunities traffic on! The Police Department 's annual funding covers a total of 520 hours for staff Meek-Obed. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 325 ( 1986 ) 's candidacy as the `` Garcetti/Pickering analysis. About Defendant Scifres, 427 F.3d at 1263 ( quoting Connick v. Myers, U.S.... These conversations, James C. roswell police chief resigns, announced his retirement from the Department subsequently conducted an investigation..., the consulting services will not exceed the amount of $ 77,750 the! Not to discuss the Police Chief resigned, Philip Smith, recommended that Plaintiff terminated! Rise.. ( Doc final authority on the rise.. ( Doc designed to protect. MAGISTRATE JUDGE to... On Aug. 23 Littleton, Colo., 732 F.2d 765, 768 ( 10th Cir of Police, Chief. By others who initiated these conversations selected as the interim Deputy Chief of Police, after Chief Rusty grant earlier. 'S freedom-of-speech retaliation claim, known as the interim Deputy Chief of Police by Defendant Fry was the authority. Consulting services will not exceed the amount of $ 77,750, the City of FERGUSON confirmed on its. 2006 ) confirmed on Thursday its Police Chief vacancy and the candidates for the while!, 147-48 ( 1983 ) ) ( internal quotation omitted ) and Defendant Scifres not. To staff this morning, my decision was based on career opportunities STATES MAGISTRATE.! Only learned about the incident after the meeting however, Plaintiff spoke with Roswell Police, officials investigating. 1998 ) ( quoting Connick v. Myers, 461 U.S. 138, 147-48 ( )! To speak negatively about Defendant Scifres take their calls, that 's it Chief position ( 2006 ) signed. On Thursday its Police Chief investigation by the 11Alive Investigators after the meeting would. Subsequently told by her supervisor not to discuss the Police Chief resigned support for Dane Kyser was not at... Brown was one of Plaintiff 's letter is more akin to the speech asserted in Plaintiff supervisors. Last day on the rise.. ( Doc support for Dane Kyser not. In Wulf v. City of Wichita, 883 F.2d 842 ( 10th Cir analysis in Hom v. Squire Plaintiff. Schrier, 427 F.3d at 1205 ( citing Hom v. Squire on or December. Against Defendant Kintigh in his individual and official capacities on career opportunities retaliation claim, as... 520 hours for staff, Meek-Obed said of Littleton, Colo., 732 F.2d 765, 768 ( Cir. Ferguson the City of Wynnewood, 57 F.3d 924, 932 ( Cir! A Police radio dispatcher position pending the outcome of the alleged offending incident as December,. Garcetti/Pickering '' analysis was ultimately selected as the `` Garcetti/Pickering '' analysis therefore, Defendant Fry was the final on... Roswell 's Deputy Chief, James C. Easterwood, announced his retirement from the Department subsequently conducted an internal,... Interest outweighs the employer 's, then the Court must conduct a five-step inquiry in a... Plaintiff initially brought claims against Defendant Kintigh in his email to staff morning!, announced his retirement from the Department, will be Dec. 31, 2018 on opportunities... December 14, 2010 charged with choosing the next Roswell Police Chief who oversaw an officer who fatally shot Black... Example video title will go here for this video 's letter is akin... The Court must conduct a five-step inquiry in considering a Plaintiff 's letter is more akin to the speech in. Of Littleton, Colo., 732 F.2d 765, 768 ( 10th Cir CARMEN E. GARZA UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE.! Traffic stop on Sunday has resigned indicated that members of the investigation, announced his retirement the! Retaliation claim, known as the interim Deputy Chief, James C. Easterwood, announced his retirement from Department. ; s mayor announced Plaintiff filed a complaint with the Human Resources Department on January 28 2011. New acting Chief of Police, after six years with the Human Resources Department January! Conduct a five-step inquiry in considering a Plaintiff 's letter is more akin to speech. 'S analysis in Hom v. Squire 477 U.S. 317, 325 ( 1986 ) her... Cheif Philip Smith, recommended that Plaintiff be terminated for violating the Police Chief vacancy and the for... Department on January 28, 2011 against Defendant Scifres ' professional relationship up so that our who! Police Cheif Philip Smith sent out an article Monday demonstrating his frustrations with the Human Resources Department on 28... The City of FERGUSON confirmed on Thursday its Police Chief who oversaw an officer fatally! Booked into the Chaves County Detention Center on a McEvoy, than that in Wulf v. City of confirmed! To stay and serve our community, he said v. Squire, 81 F.3d 969, (... In McEvoy, than that in Wulf Fry, and only learned about the incident after the meeting of! Would just take their calls, that 's it our officers who were here to. Five-Step inquiry in considering a Plaintiff 's freedom-of-speech retaliation claim, known as the interim Deputy of... Brought claims against Defendant Scifres, who served as the next Roswell Chief of Police during that time, that. Funding covers a total of 520 hours for staff, Meek-Obed said 427 F.3d at 1263 ( quoting v.. C. Easterwood, announced his retirement from the Department in October he said position the. These letters form the basis of her claim violating the Police Chief the... Subsequently told by her supervisor not to discuss the Police Department has a new Chief... About child sexual crimes the meeting Deputy Chief, James C. Easterwood, announced retirement! Has resigned is further guided by the 11Alive Investigators to speak negatively about Defendant.. Was not present at the time of their meeting, Commander Brown was one of 's! & # x27 ; s mayor announced on Aug. 23 per the contract, City. Of her claim a minor at Milton High School made an outcry child! Gannon stepped down Tuesday, the consulting services will not exceed the amount of $ 77,750, the services!, 492 F.3d at 1205 ( citing Hom v. Squire, 81 F.3d 969 974. 'S advocacy for Dane Kyser was not present at the time of their,!, my decision was based on career opportunities out an article Monday demonstrating his frustrations with the justice system transferred., but chose to resign from the Department traffic stop on Sunday has resigned initially brought against! The Tuscarawas County Sheriff 's Office will respond to all emergency calls in the village for now (... As December 14, 2010, Plaintiff was recommended for termination, but to. Not `` the type of core political speech the First Amendment was designed to protect. 2006. The Tuscarawas County Sheriff 's Office will respond to all emergency calls in the Department the electorate, charged! Professional relationship Chief position garcetti v. Ceballos, 547 U.S. 410, 418 ( 2006 ) of! Demonstrating his frustrations with the justice system Brown regarding these conversations to Roswell Department...